We visited this restaurant as part of a media tour courtesy of the Hamilton County Visitors Bureau. We were not asked for positive reviews--just to come visit and share our experiences. All opinions are our own and were not influenced by the sites visited or by our hosts.
Have you heard of the Big Ugly burger challenge? It seems that Bub's Burgers and Ice Cream is relatively famous for its 1-Pound Big Ugly burger challenge--and larger food challenges like the 4-Pound Big Ugly that attracted Man vs. Food to the site a while back. The walls of Bub's are lined with diners who have successfully completely the 1-Pound Big Ugly challenge.
The atmosphere of Bub's Burgers and Ice Cream is pretty lively. We visited on a Friday evening--and it was a loud, active place! There was music playing, televisions going, and diners at every table. If the weather is good--and you want a quieter dining experience, request to sit outdoors. Service was a little slow since they were so busy--but, there was never a point where we did not have drink refills or our needs met.
Okay--How was the Food at Bub's Burgers and Ice Cream? I am amazed by the number of people who have won the Bub's Big Ugly 1-Pound Challenge--my french fries were virtually untouched as I struggled to finish my Settle for Less Ugly 1/4 Pound Burger!
The girls, who never agree on anything, thought the Busy Bags were a neat change of pace. The simple hand-colored, paper bags serve up individual bags of Goldfish crackers and fruit snacks to keep antsy little ones distracted until the meal arrives!
Both girls chose corn dog meals from the Little Bubs kids meal selections--one with waffle fries and one with onion rings. I can say that the beer battered onion rings were really good--I traded a few french fries to convince my youngest to give up one onion ring!
While my girls went for some unhealthy options, there were better choices on the Little Bubs kid's menu--like mixed vegetables and applesauce!
Would I recommend Bub's Burgers and Ice Cream? Bub's Burgers and Ice Cream is a fun, casual place that is perfectly suited to families. The prices are reasonable, the portions are huge and the atmosphere is lively and upbeat. If you find yourself in Carmel and want a really good (or really BIG) burger or hot dog--I would certainly check out Bub's Burgers and Ice Cream. It does get crowded--and loud--and it's nothing "fancy". The menu offerings are simple--and they do offer lighter food choices (like grilled mahi mahi or a portabello mushroom sandwich). It's just a fun, family friendly lunch or dinner spot that I would visit again when we return to the area.
If you go:
Expect to wait during peak meal times--and dress for the weather since the waiting area will likely spill over to the outside. I wouldn't recommend leaving the restaurant once you have your name on the wait list--they are so busy that you may find yourself bumped down the list if your name is called and you aren't present to be seated.
Plan to walk through at least a bit of the Carmel Arts and Design District during your visit. There is so much to see and do in the area--and you'll already have a parking space.
Visit and Connect
Bub's Burgers and Ice Cream
210 W. Main Street Carmel, Indiana 46032