One time, I had the bright idea to celebrate National Pizza Day by making a pizza at home, from scratch. Let’s just say it was all fun and games until the pizza didn’t turn out as planned…overbaked in some areas, undercooked in others. This didn’t satisfy my craving for a warm, cheesy pizza on a thick, crunchy crust – with breadsticks on the side, of course.
So take my advice and leave it to the experts and dine-in or carry-out a pipin’ hot pizza pie. We worked with Yelp Indy to find the top places to order a pizza in Hamilton County. Happy eating!
Methodology: This is an all-time list of the top ten restaurants with pizza in Hamilton County, according to Yelp. We identified businesses in the restaurant category that mentioned pizza in reviews and are not part of a national chain, then ranked those spots using a number of factors including the total volume and ratings of reviews. This list was updated in January 2024.
1. I Tre Mori
8220 E. 106th St., Ste. 200, Fishers
Yelp Insight
“What a gem! I Tre Mori is some of the best woodfired pizza I’ve had the pleasure of eating in central Indiana. The crust is chewy yet crispy with a slightly char-dusted bottom. They use San Marzano tomatoes for their sauce. They have a cozy, intimate bar area set off to the side just for adults. They have a magnificent wine menu. It’s the perfect place for people who like good food and drink.” – Yelper Nicole S.
2. Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse
2430 E. 146th St., Carmel
Yelp Insight
“Crafters is absolutely amazing! The sweet Thai chili wings and pizzas are easily among the best I’ve ever tasted. Combine the great food with great service, and this is an easy 5-star review. Cannot wait to come back and try different pizza and wing flavors.” – Yelper Seth D.
3. Passione
11640 Brooks School Rd., Fishers
Yelp Insight
“Guys, this place is the real deal. If you are looking for REAL, authentic Italian pizza, look no further! They only use the highest quality of fresh ingredients. We had the pizza 4 Formaggio (4 cheese) and pizza Montanari (ricotta cheese, home-made sausage, and mushroom). Both were absolutely perfect and delicious.” – Yelper Ka’Lena J.
4. Bronko's Pizza and Sandwich Shop
90 W. Jackson St., Cicero
Yelp Insight
“Bronkos is some of the best pizza I have ever had. It has the perfect amount of toppings and a thick layer of cheese on top. It is honestly some of my favorite pizza ever. We have it at least once every 2 weeks. I cannot recommend it more!” – Yelper Corey S.
5. Rockstone Pizza Pub
11501 Allisonville Road, Fishers
Yelp Insight
“What an incredible devour deal!! 1 appetizer, 2 salads, two entrees and a dessert! On top of that there were so many good options to choose from it was hard to narrow it down!...After such an amazing food experience I will definitely be back to try more things on the menu.” – Yelper Olivia O.
6. Saxony Pizzeria
13578 131st St., Ste. 105, Fishers
Yelp Insight
“Detroit style pizza?!?! What more could you ask for! Place is legit! Great pizza, calzones and sticks. Staff is always fantastic too!” – Yelper Ryan A.
7. Pizza by the Harbour
20813 Hague Rd., Noblesville
Yelp Insight
“My family loves Pizza by the Harbour! We are never disappointed, have tried numerous specialty options along with the traditional and thin crust and everything is delicious. Highly recommend for your next pizza night!” – Yelper Abigail S.
8. Greek Tony’s Pizza & Sub Shop
1732 E. 116th St., Carmel
Yelp Insight
“Being a food influencer, moved from California…I have had my fair share of pizzas from a lot of different places. This pizza place knocks all those out of the park.” – Yelper Jenna Y.
9. Queenie's Pizza at Sun King Carmel
351 Monon Blvd., Carmel
Yelp Insight
“Great pizza from Queenie’s pizza, tacos or Mexican flavors from La Margarita and great local flavors from The Den by Foxgardin are all the great food options at Sun King in Carmel. All pair with a yummy Sun King on draft!” – Yelper Sable S.
10. Chicago's Pizza
13204 Market Square Dr., Fishers
Yelp Insight
“There are a lot of places you can get pizza from, but when I tell you Chicago’s is by far the BEST! It’s by far the best. I absolutely love their pizza sauce and all the ingredients are fresh and they don’t skimp on the toppings either…If you’re craving a good pizza, this is the place.” – Yelper Andrea P.
40+ Pizza Places
If this list doesn't tempt your tastebuds, view a complete list of more than 40 restaurants in Hamilton County, Indiana serving pizza.
For more information on places to eat in Hamilton County, visit our restaurants page and be sure to follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.