Hot New Restaurants in Hamilton County

Ash & Elm Cider Co.

Ash & Elm Cider Co. recently opened a new location in Carmel, bringing its signature casual dining and regionally sourced ciders to the up-and-coming North End neighborhood. Here, you’ll find the largest selection of ciders on tap in the state, serving everything from dry and sweet versions of classic brews to chili guava cider, pineapple-tamarind, and other funky flavor combinations.

BuffaLouie’s

The beloved wings joint BuffaLouie’s has opened a new location on Main Street in Carmel, offering their famous boneless (and traditional wings), along with burgers, sandwiches, and more. Established in 1987, BuffaLouie’s is an Indiana institution and the perfect spot to satisfy your comfort food cravings!

Lone Pine

Lone Pine, one of our most raved restaurants in 2024, recently opened in the Carmel City Center. This steakhouse was founded by James-Beard-nominated Josh Mazanowski and features high-quality, locally sourced steaks and a French-inspired menu. It’s the perfect place for a date night or special celebration—diners buzz about its inventive menu and cozy atmosphere. With its growing reputation, Lone Pine is poised to become one of the top dining destinations in Hamilton County!

Tre on Main

Tre on Main brings authentic Italian flavors to the heart of Carmel, offering a thoughtfully curated menu in a stylish yet welcoming setting. Diners rave about the pan-seared salmon, often called the best in town, and the squid ink pasta, praised for its bold flavors and striking presentation. An extensive wine list ensures the perfect pairing for any dish, while attentive service from their friendly staff adds a personal touch. 

Cafe Patachou Nickel Plate 

Cafe Patachou has brought its beloved all-day breakfast and lunch experience to Fishers with its newest location on 116th Street. Known for scratch-made dishes crafted with premium, locally sourced ingredients, the café has earned national recognition, including a nod from “Bon Appétit Magazine” as one of the top breakfast spots in the country! Enjoy signature omelets, fresh salads, and house-made desserts in a beautifully designed space featuring cozy banquette seating and patio dining along the Nickel Plate Trail.

Kura Revolving Sushi Bar

Kura Revolving Sushi Bar opened its first Indiana location in Fishers. This award-winning restaurant offers an authentic Japanese experience, with a healthy spread of sushi, soups, noodles, and desserts served on a conveyor belt, making for a unique dining experience. In addition to Kura, several new restaurants are slated to open soon in Fishers, including exciting additions planned for The Union at Fishers District expansion, so stay tuned!

Max & Tilly's

Max & Tilly's is a charming new addition to Fishers, Indiana, offering a delightful taste of British cuisine. Specializing in authentic fish and chips, this eatery also features a diverse menu that includes hearty sandwiches, refreshing salads, and delectable desserts like scones with clotted cream. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service make it a perfect spot for both casual dining and special occasions. Whether you're craving comfort food or looking to try something new, Max & Tilly's promises a memorable dining experience.

Mochi Joy Donuts

Mochi Joy Donuts has recently opened a new location in Fishers.. This charming shop specializes in Hawaiian-style mochi donuts, known for their unique chewy texture and crisp exterior. The new store features a variety of rotating flavors, a coffee bar and even Hawaiian-inspired cakes and shortbread cookies.

Tiburon Coastal Cuisine

Though Tiburon Coastal Cuisine opened its doors in the Nickel Plate District a couple of years ago, it remains one of the most exciting and sought-after dining destinations in Fishers. With a fresh sushi bar and coastal classics like lobster bisque, oysters, and even a seafood tower, this is the place to go when you’re craving seaside flavors in the midwest. 

Bar Ellis 

Bar Ellis is gearing up to open in downtown Noblesville, promising an elevated twist on comfort food favorites like chicken and noodles, pork schnitzel, and bacon-wrapped shrimp. Vegetarians will also find plant-based options to enjoy. And the fun doesn’t stop after dinner—Bar Ellis plans to stay open until midnight on weekends, featuring live entertainment to keep the good vibes going!

Casa Santa

Casa Santa opened in Noblesville in 2024, expanding the local dining scene by offering an upscale Mexican restaurant experience. Casa Santa offers an inviting ambiance paired with a menu highlighting Mexican-American and Tex-Mex favorites like fajitas, burritos, carne asada, and quesadillas. For those seeking something unique, the menu also includes freshly made seafood ceviches and even grasshopper toppings for the more adventurous taco enthusiasts!

CourtHouse Club

The CourtHouse Club in Downtown Noblesville’s historic square offers an upscale dining experience in a sleek, modern setting with a hint of speakeasy charm. Known for its standout dishes like Black & Blue Flatbread, gumbo, and fried goat cheese salad, the menu is complemented by expertly crafted cocktails, including a must-try espresso martini. 

Nyla’s 

Nyla’s is the newest addition to Westfield’s Restaurant Row, offering two cocktail bars and classic (but elevated) Americana cooking inside a repurposed barn. The restaurant feels homey yet upscale, with menu items like fried green tomatoes, cornbread, chicken Milanese, and their famous pork chop smothered in tomato bacon jam. Nyla’s caters to folks 21 and older, so it’s an ideal date night spot for dinner and drinks.

Gringtinos

A local couple recently opened Gringtinos, bringing their long-time culinary dream to life in the heart of Westfield. Founded by a Bolivian-American duo of chefs, this place offers a multicultural menu that blends classic pub fare from North and South America. Whether you’re craving empanadas, tacos, pretzels, or buffalo wings, you’ll find something delicious while enjoying live music or partaking in their trivia nights.

Northbrook Brewing Company

Northbrook Brewing Company is another reason to get excited about Hamilton County’s craft beer scene. Opened in Arcadia in 2023, this brewery crafts a diverse lineup of beers, from classic pilsners and IPAs to bold creations like their blackberry and Thai basil sour. Complement your drink with pub favorites like flatbreads, sandwiches, and shareable appetizers, making it the perfect spot to gather with friends.

Dark Side Roasters and Coffee House

Although this coffee shop opened in 2020, Dark Side Roasters Coffee House continues to be one of Cicero's most exciting additions. This local favorite is celebrated for roasting and brewing top-notch coffee, along with smoothies and freshly baked pastries. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic cup of joe or a handcrafted espresso drink, it’s the perfect spot for a mid-day pick-me-up!